 |
| Yoshiko Yamaguchi |
1945. Harumi (Yoshiko Yamaguchi) is a singer in a troupe of female
entertainers sent to Manchuria to help the Japanese soldiers forget about their
probable imminent deaths. Unfortunately, she quickly attracts the attention of overbearing
Lieutenant Narita (Eitaro Ozawa) and is about to be raped by him when Private
First Class Mikami (Ryo Ikebe) knocks on the door to deliver a trivial telegram
to Narita, allowing Harumi to escape. Harumi and Mikami fall in love, but, when he's wounded in battle, circumstances lead to them being captured together by the Chinese. Mikami is
treated with nothing but kindness by his captors, but he’s been completely
brainwashed by the Japanese military propaganda machine into thinking that it’s
better to die than be taken prisoner…
 |
| Eitaro Ozawa and Yamaguchi |
Produced by Shintoho,
the company founded by those who split from Toho after the studio’s big labour
dispute of 1947, Escape at Dawn was
nevertheless distributed by Toho. Like director Senkichi Taniguchi’s previous
film, Jakoman and Tetsu, it was also
produced by Tomoyuki Tanaka and co-written by Akira Kurosawa. In this case, the
source was a 1947 novel by Taijiro Tamiya (1911-83) entitled Shunpu den (‘The Story of a Prostitute’,
not available in English). Tamiya had served in Manchuria during the war (as
had Taniguchi) and also written Nikutai
no mon (‘The Gate of Flesh’), first filmed in 1948 by Masahiro Makino and
later by Seijin Suzuki, Hideo Gosha and others.
 |
| Ryo Ikebe |
Although Tamiya is said
to have created the character of Harumi with Yoshiko (later Shirley) Yamaguchi in mind, in
the novel she was a Korean prostitute (or ‘comfort woman’), while it’s made
very clear in the film that she is not a prostitute, and she has also become
Japanese. Apparently, the original version of the screenplay was faithful to
the novel on these points, but the content of Japanese films was still being
controlled by the occupying Americans, who insisted that changes be made. It’s
hard to see how such whitewashing benefitted the Americans, so their decision
was presumably just a case of them imposing their own cultural nanny-state
ideas of the time about the depiction of ‘immorality’ on screen. An unfortunate
knock-on effect was that Harumi’s behaviour in the way she throws herself at
Mikami and won’t take no for an answer now appeared extremely odd coming from a
Japanese singer rather than a Korean prostitute. According to Stuart Galbraith
IV in his book The Emperor and The Wolf,
Kurosawa eventually got fed up with the requests for endless rewrites and left
Taniguchi to it. He also states that,
…long preproduction,
expensive exterior sets, and tangled red tape to secure permission for use of
military hardware for filming (machine guns, etc) made it the most expensive
Japanese feature to that point.
I’ve read elsewhere
that it was also the first post-war Japanese film to feature scenes of Japanese soldiers
on the frontlines. In any case, while it’s certainly a compromised vision, the
film is at least very well-made and often technically impressive, with cinematographer
Akira Mimura winning a Mainichi Film Concours award for his efforts. On the
other hand, the essentially simple story of a predictably doomed romance feels
overstretched at almost two hours. As Lieutenant Narita and his men are stationed in the desert, the
film is very much like a Japanese Foreign Legion movie, and memories of Marlene
Dietrich and Gary Cooper in Morocco
(1930) are often brought to mind. There are some surprisingly sensual scenes between
stars Yoshiko Yamaguchi and Ryo Ikebe – at one point, she bites his hand hard
enough to draw blood, then sucks the wound, which he seems to enjoy. This would
have been considered strong stuff in Japan in 1950 and probably helped at the
box office.
Seijun Suzuki directed a more faithful version of the original
novel in 1965.
Bonus trivia:
Setsuko Wakayama, who
plays one of Harumi’s colleagues, had married director Senkichi Taniguchi in
1949, but they divorced in 1956 when he had an affair with actress Kaoru Yachigusa.
This adultery scandal harmed Taniguchi’s career greatly – after directing an
average of three films a year until 1957, he was subsequently out of work for
over two years. When he did return to directing, the quality of the material he
was offered was significantly lower than it had been before the scandal.
 |
| Setsuko Wakayama |
DVD at Amazon Japan (no English subtitles)